The Chronicles of Narnia: The Voyage of the Dawn Treader (2010)
Directed by Michael Apted. Starring Ben Barnes, Skandar Keynes, and Georgie Henley.
When a franchise changes hands for the first time, it can lead to trouble. Sure, you've got your James Bonds and Harry Potters which have survived multiple creative shifts, but for every one of these, there's another several that didn't succeed. (This is particularly true of comic book movies... X-Men and Spiderman come to mind -- but more on that soon). After being the creative force and the studio behind both The Lion, The Witch, and the Wardrobe and Prince Caspian, both Andrew Adams and Disney sat this one out. Still, it was full force ahead under Walden Media. (On a less obvious note, the composer of the first two films, Harry Gregson-Williams also did not return... to my particular and great disappointment).
Still, The Voyage of the Dawn Treader brings the book to life, is adventurous and entertaining, and is reasonably true to the spirit of the franchise thus far. It's been a while since I've read the book, so it was nice to rediscover the story with the film. Much like Prince Caspian, it takes certain liberties to make it a more interesting movie -- for once, in my opinion, there's actually not enough material in the book for the film, and this has been true with the last few, if not all, Narnia movies. That's what makes them such great film adaptations. They can bring the books to life and, in a sense, improve on them.
Dawn Treader is a very different story from the other two. It's not structured around a single enemy and doesn't climax with a battle. Instead, it's an adventure-on-the-high-seas tale, a treasure hunt that takes our characters to strange and scary lands beyond the edge of the map. The film modifies this with a mysterious "green mist" that, in a sense, is the "bad guy" of the story. So, for anyone feeling fatigued by the structure of Prince Caspian resembling the storyline of Lion/Witch/Wardrobe, this film is relatively fresh.
Additionally, the faces change. If you haven't read the Narnia books, you may not be familiar with this, but nearly every book introduces a new character or two, who then carries on the series in the next. The Pevensies begin in Lion/Witch/Wardrobe and return in Prince Caspian... but by Dawn Treader, Peter and Susan are too old for Narnia. So, this time, it's just Edmund and Lucy, except that they accidentally bring along their annoying cousin Eustace. (Eustace later goes on to return to Narnia in the next book, with his friend Polly, who then returns without him in the book after that). Caspian is back (though interestingly, Ben Barnes dropped the Mediterranean accent and reverted to his native British lilt this time around... awkward at first, but better all around in the end).
I'm writing this after my second viewing of the film -- the first in theaters, the second with some of the kids I babysit. Both times, I noticed that the audience was younger than I would have thought. Overall, I think these films lack the darkness and intensity that, say, can be found in a rival fantasy franchise, The Lord of the Rings, something that I would wager is the leading factor in drawing in an older demographic. Still, the film is an entertaining, Disney-esque film (though it now lacks Disney) that is fitting "on the shelf" next to the first two. It is a pity that this series has dropped off (in terms of box office and popular interest), as it's looking unlikely that future books will be adapted onscreen (at least with this generation of actors -- in the future, who knows?)
In the end, and I think I'm qualified to say this, fans of the series won't be disappointed in seeing this next book in the series brought to life. Though it lacks the scale and grandeur of the first two, it is still imaginative and spectacular in its representation of Narnia.
This is a film blog by an avid movie-goer, for the movie-goers of the world. I seek to lift the tone of film reviews from overly critical to thoughtful. As a student in Film Studies and a hopeful future filmmaker, I attempt to bring my knowledge of the film industry and its history to bear on the films I write about -- whether the latest summer Blockbuster, or a timeless classic, and anything in between.
Showing posts with label Second Viewing. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Second Viewing. Show all posts
Saturday, April 23, 2011
Friday, April 22, 2011
The King's Speech
The King's Speech (2010)
Directed by Tom Hooper. Starring Collin Firth, Geoffrey Rush, and Helena Bonham Carter.
83rd Oscars - 8 Nominations and 4 Won: Best Picture, Best Director (Tom Hooper), Best Original Screenplay (David Seidler), Best Actor Leading Role (Collin Firth)
Several months ago, The King's Speech won Best Picture, along with a number of other awards, at the 83rd Oscar Ceremony. Some people were disappointed in this winning -- let me say right off that I was not one of them. Sure, there's the argument that Inception was a more interesting film, the kind the Academy needs to branch out and start awarding (I agree with that). And, sure, The Social Network was more a film "for my generation" (I also think that's right)... But The King's Speech is a solid, well-made, well-acted, well-done film, well worth praising. I'm writing this after viewing it a second time, since it's now on DVD, so I can safely say I see its merits.
I mean, what's not to like? It's a feel-good, underdog tale, a slice of history and a biopic, starring two talented and - until recently - wildly underrated actors, and an actress who is such a surprising chameleon that she can play the Queen's Mother at the same time she's filming Harry Potter! Several months out, I think lot of the negative comments regarding this winning Big Picture distill into one argument: it is too Oscary. In other words, the Academy rewards too many pictures of this nature - stories of someone overcoming hardship, battling something (in this case, a speech defect), and rising above your problems to triumph in the public sphere. (Seriously, glance at a list of Best Picture winners. So many of them fit this formula).
So, yes, this film is a bit predictable - at least, predictable as a winner. The biggest complaint about the 83rd Oscar Ceremony was that the whole night was a bore; the biggest surprise was Kirk Douglas's presentation of the Best Supporting Actress category. (For the record, I still enjoyed the show, but I always get carried away by the glitz and glamour!) If you share this viewpoint, I encourage you to try looking at it another way: in The King's Speech, these filmmakers managed to make gold (literally) out of a tried and true filmic setup.... They managed to take something that's been done and done again, and still do it well! Any-who... In my opinion, The King's Speech makes a good addition to the Best Picture category. *steps off soapbox*
On a personal note, I really loved this film - both times watching it! Reading/watching ANYTHING about British history is one of my favorite pastimes, and it was interesting to learn about a king I knew little about, other than his relationship to Elizabeth II. I've already said that I adore Geoffrey Rush in my Pirates review... And so I enjoyed watching him take on, shall we say, a more substantial performance. Rush is delightfully eccentric and - for all that Collin Firth manages that st-st-stammer quite well - darn near carries the film. (It's a pity Rush didn't carry away a trophy as well). Speaking of Firth, he manages a transformation INTO Bertie, the second son who never wanted to be King. He is a man who must find his own inner strength in order to show said strength to his nation in a time of great hardship. He really brings this man to life. The film is emotional, yet uplifting. It carries you away yet somehow manages to speak to your own life. Bravo!
Directed by Tom Hooper. Starring Collin Firth, Geoffrey Rush, and Helena Bonham Carter.
83rd Oscars - 8 Nominations and 4 Won: Best Picture, Best Director (Tom Hooper), Best Original Screenplay (David Seidler), Best Actor Leading Role (Collin Firth)
Several months ago, The King's Speech won Best Picture, along with a number of other awards, at the 83rd Oscar Ceremony. Some people were disappointed in this winning -- let me say right off that I was not one of them. Sure, there's the argument that Inception was a more interesting film, the kind the Academy needs to branch out and start awarding (I agree with that). And, sure, The Social Network was more a film "for my generation" (I also think that's right)... But The King's Speech is a solid, well-made, well-acted, well-done film, well worth praising. I'm writing this after viewing it a second time, since it's now on DVD, so I can safely say I see its merits.
I mean, what's not to like? It's a feel-good, underdog tale, a slice of history and a biopic, starring two talented and - until recently - wildly underrated actors, and an actress who is such a surprising chameleon that she can play the Queen's Mother at the same time she's filming Harry Potter! Several months out, I think lot of the negative comments regarding this winning Big Picture distill into one argument: it is too Oscary. In other words, the Academy rewards too many pictures of this nature - stories of someone overcoming hardship, battling something (in this case, a speech defect), and rising above your problems to triumph in the public sphere. (Seriously, glance at a list of Best Picture winners. So many of them fit this formula).
So, yes, this film is a bit predictable - at least, predictable as a winner. The biggest complaint about the 83rd Oscar Ceremony was that the whole night was a bore; the biggest surprise was Kirk Douglas's presentation of the Best Supporting Actress category. (For the record, I still enjoyed the show, but I always get carried away by the glitz and glamour!) If you share this viewpoint, I encourage you to try looking at it another way: in The King's Speech, these filmmakers managed to make gold (literally) out of a tried and true filmic setup.... They managed to take something that's been done and done again, and still do it well! Any-who... In my opinion, The King's Speech makes a good addition to the Best Picture category. *steps off soapbox*
On a personal note, I really loved this film - both times watching it! Reading/watching ANYTHING about British history is one of my favorite pastimes, and it was interesting to learn about a king I knew little about, other than his relationship to Elizabeth II. I've already said that I adore Geoffrey Rush in my Pirates review... And so I enjoyed watching him take on, shall we say, a more substantial performance. Rush is delightfully eccentric and - for all that Collin Firth manages that st-st-stammer quite well - darn near carries the film. (It's a pity Rush didn't carry away a trophy as well). Speaking of Firth, he manages a transformation INTO Bertie, the second son who never wanted to be King. He is a man who must find his own inner strength in order to show said strength to his nation in a time of great hardship. He really brings this man to life. The film is emotional, yet uplifting. It carries you away yet somehow manages to speak to your own life. Bravo!
Thursday, March 31, 2011
Close Encounters of the Third Kind
Close Encounters of the Third Kind (1977)
Directed by Steven Spielberg. Starring Richard Dreyfuss and Francois Truffaut.
Though it may not seem fitting at first, Close Encounters is an excellent follow-up film to discuss after Bonnie & Clyde. Let's follow the timeline... Interestingly, the New Hollywood generation of films I talked about yesterday quickly lead to the Blockbuster era of filmmaking. There are some positively classic examples of the early Blockbuster films, all of which I mentioned in my previous post (The Godfather, Jaws, and Star Wars were all key), and Close Encounters is also in the same vein. Just look at the year it was released... 1977. It's hard to think of Spielberg's alien film in conjunction with the release of the game changing Star Wars Episode IV: A New Hope, and I'm sure one overshadowed the other, but bad timing aside, Close Encounters of the Third Kind remains an intriguing UFO film rivaled only perhaps by Contact.
I had seen Close Encounters before viewing it again in my film history class -- of course. Spielberg is a fantastic filmmaker, and I'm sure I wasn't the only kid who grew up with E.T. then graduated to this as a more adult film version of a film about humans meeting aliens. Amazingly, this film really stands the test of time... We watched it in class on Blu-Ray on our nice large projection screen and it was *almost* like it would have been seeing it in theaters. To be honest, I was actually surprised how good even the spaceship and aliens at the end look... a little aged, perhaps, but in general, the special effects were quite well done for the 70s.
I find this movie interesting because it's particularly memorable to everyone who's seen it. Ask anyone what they remember, and I bet you'll hear a whistled version of the theme music, a joke about mashed potatoes, and a comment about the Devil's Tower. These things just stay with you. But there is more to the film than that, of course. Close Encounters is about believing in the impossible, and having others not believe in you. It's about children and adults seeing the world differently (as many of Spielberg's films are), and I think the film encourages a certainly childlike openness and wonder in the audience. In the end, it's wonderful to see a science fiction film that can hold its own in the annals of film history.
Though perhaps this film falls into the beginning of the era when Hollywood began caring more about Box Office returns than the quality of every storyline, I DON'T think Close Encounters is an example of a film or filmmaker that sold out. Okay, sure, this was a film that was made for roughly $19 million and made $300+ million, but this isn't a popcorn film like today's Transformers franchise... it's imaginative and creative. It made money, I'm sure, because people thought it was new and intriguing, and well-made. It's one of those movies where all of its pieces come together brilliantly -- from the special effects to John William's wondrous soundtrack to Richard Dreyfuss's manic acting. So, instead of seeing it already as a Hollywood Blockbuster, I think this film -- and others of the same period, like Star Wars -- mark the transition between "New Hollywood" and the Blockbuster era. Spielberg was still trying something new, like others in the 60s and 70s in Hollywood, but he was beginning to see that he could make money doing so. Still, he's aware of what came before... sci fi like 2001: Space Odyssey and even film history. (Fun fact: In an interesting nod to the French New Wave, which inspired many of the "movie brats," including Spielberg, it seems, the French scientist in Close Encounters is played by French filmmaker Francois Truffaut.)
Close Encounters is the best of both worlds... a smashing hit that is also an entertaining thrill. It's a film with a little bit of melodrama, some romance, a conspiracy theory or two, and plenty of eerie "close encounters" with flying saucers. This is a timeless hit that's worth seeing at any age.
Directed by Steven Spielberg. Starring Richard Dreyfuss and Francois Truffaut.
Though it may not seem fitting at first, Close Encounters is an excellent follow-up film to discuss after Bonnie & Clyde. Let's follow the timeline... Interestingly, the New Hollywood generation of films I talked about yesterday quickly lead to the Blockbuster era of filmmaking. There are some positively classic examples of the early Blockbuster films, all of which I mentioned in my previous post (The Godfather, Jaws, and Star Wars were all key), and Close Encounters is also in the same vein. Just look at the year it was released... 1977. It's hard to think of Spielberg's alien film in conjunction with the release of the game changing Star Wars Episode IV: A New Hope, and I'm sure one overshadowed the other, but bad timing aside, Close Encounters of the Third Kind remains an intriguing UFO film rivaled only perhaps by Contact.
I had seen Close Encounters before viewing it again in my film history class -- of course. Spielberg is a fantastic filmmaker, and I'm sure I wasn't the only kid who grew up with E.T. then graduated to this as a more adult film version of a film about humans meeting aliens. Amazingly, this film really stands the test of time... We watched it in class on Blu-Ray on our nice large projection screen and it was *almost* like it would have been seeing it in theaters. To be honest, I was actually surprised how good even the spaceship and aliens at the end look... a little aged, perhaps, but in general, the special effects were quite well done for the 70s.
I find this movie interesting because it's particularly memorable to everyone who's seen it. Ask anyone what they remember, and I bet you'll hear a whistled version of the theme music, a joke about mashed potatoes, and a comment about the Devil's Tower. These things just stay with you. But there is more to the film than that, of course. Close Encounters is about believing in the impossible, and having others not believe in you. It's about children and adults seeing the world differently (as many of Spielberg's films are), and I think the film encourages a certainly childlike openness and wonder in the audience. In the end, it's wonderful to see a science fiction film that can hold its own in the annals of film history.
Though perhaps this film falls into the beginning of the era when Hollywood began caring more about Box Office returns than the quality of every storyline, I DON'T think Close Encounters is an example of a film or filmmaker that sold out. Okay, sure, this was a film that was made for roughly $19 million and made $300+ million, but this isn't a popcorn film like today's Transformers franchise... it's imaginative and creative. It made money, I'm sure, because people thought it was new and intriguing, and well-made. It's one of those movies where all of its pieces come together brilliantly -- from the special effects to John William's wondrous soundtrack to Richard Dreyfuss's manic acting. So, instead of seeing it already as a Hollywood Blockbuster, I think this film -- and others of the same period, like Star Wars -- mark the transition between "New Hollywood" and the Blockbuster era. Spielberg was still trying something new, like others in the 60s and 70s in Hollywood, but he was beginning to see that he could make money doing so. Still, he's aware of what came before... sci fi like 2001: Space Odyssey and even film history. (Fun fact: In an interesting nod to the French New Wave, which inspired many of the "movie brats," including Spielberg, it seems, the French scientist in Close Encounters is played by French filmmaker Francois Truffaut.)
Close Encounters is the best of both worlds... a smashing hit that is also an entertaining thrill. It's a film with a little bit of melodrama, some romance, a conspiracy theory or two, and plenty of eerie "close encounters" with flying saucers. This is a timeless hit that's worth seeing at any age.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)


